6 Best First Base Mitts in 2024 | Coach Picked.

As a former player and current baseball coach, I know firsthand how crucial quality gear can be. And if you’re going to be playing first base, you’ll need a quality mitt.

In my first year playing first base, I had a hard time making plays and fielding balls cleanly because I was using a hand-me-down mitt that was too small and worn out. But after purchasing a top-quality first base mitt, my game completely shifted.

Suddenly, I could reach far and wide to pick up my teammates’ low tosses easily. The proper mitt gave me the confidence to improve my game.

As a coach, I now emphasize the significance of high-quality gear to all of my players. I’ll be detailing some of the best first base mitts now available in this article.

Best First Base Mitts for Baseball

WILSON A2K 2800-W Baseball First Base Glove Mitt

Special Features

• High-Quality Pro Stock Leather Guarantees a Perfect Fit and Lasts for Years.
• There is a deep pocket and a safety catch in the design of the dual post web.
• Dri-Lex wrist liner to prevent sweat from building up while you play.
• A simple and adaptable technique for a perfect fit every time.
• Crafted by hand to ensure the highest quality and finest finish.

I played baseball in the past, so I understand the significance of having quality gear.

You need a quality mitt if you want to make the game-changing plays and turn the double plays as a first baseman. I’ve used and loved the Wilson A2000 2800 12.5″ Baseball First Base Mitt, and I think any first baseman would too.

During my playing career, I was able to try out several different mitts, but the Wilson A2000 2800 consistently impressed me as the best of the bunch. Nothing beats the Pro Stock leather structure for durability and comfort for extended days on the field. The mitt’s Dual Post Web provides a deep pocket and a secure catch, facilitating both fielding and throwing.

Among the many things that impressed me about the A2000 2800 was the care used in its construction. The mitt has been hand-stitched by master artisans, who have taken great care to ensure that every stitch is in the exact right location.

With the custom fit system’s simple adjustments and tailored fit, it’s like having an extra set of hands.

I have had nothing but good luck with the Wilson A2000 2800. All serious players and coaches should have this mitt because of its superior performance, longevity, and comfort. The Wilson A2000 2800 is an excellent choice if you need a first base mitt that won’t let you down.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Pro Stock leather construction ensures long wear and a great feel.
• The large pocket and secure catch provided by the Dual Post Web design facilitate both fielding and accurate throwing.
• The Dri-Lex lining at the wrist will keep your hands dry and comfortable even in the most intense games.
• An easily adjustable and adaptable custom fit system.
• Every mitt is made with care and attention to detail by skilled artisans.

Cons:

• The expense is high compared to other mitts available.
• Some players may be unable to comfortably use a 12.5″ bat because their hands are too tiny.

2023 Wilson A2000® 1679SS 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt

Special Features

• Built using Pro Stock Leather, which guarantees longevity, uniformity, and pleasant touch.
• This sturdy and supportive web design features two rows of horizontal bars.
• Precision and quality are guaranteed by the handcrafted nature of the construction.
• The Dri-Lex lining in the wrist area is great for preventing sweaty hands.
• An easily adjustable and adaptable custom fit system.

Although I did not get to use it during my playing days, I have tried many different mitts over the years. And this one has always stuck out to me because of its superior craftsmanship and performance.

The Pro Stock Leather structure was one of the first things that drew my attention to it. This mitt is made from high-quality leather, which lives up to its reputation for longevity, uniformity, and comfort.

A Double Horizontal Bars Web is incorporated into the mitt for more support and stability when catching the ball.

The fine craftsmanship of this mitt was what won me over the most. The mitt is made by hand by trained artisans, who take great care to lay each stitch precisely. The mitt’s Dri-Lex wrist liner is also a nice touch, as it keeps your hand dry and comfortable even in the hottest games.

The Wilson A2000 1679SS Baseball First Base Mitt has been a great investment for me. Because of its high level of performance, durability, and comfort, this mitt is widely favored by professional players and their coaches.

The Wilson A2000 1679SS is an excellent choice for first basemen searching for a durable, high-quality glove.

Learn more on Wilson a2K vs A2000

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• High-quality pro stock leather was used in the making of this product.
• This sturdy and supportive web design features two rows of horizontal bars.
• The great quality and attention to detail of handiwork are guaranteed.
• The Dri-Lex lining in the wrist area is great for preventing sweaty hands.
• An easily adjustable and adaptable custom fit system.

Cons:

• Can be expensive for some players.
• It could be too uncomfortable for some players.

Mizuno GXF102 Youth(Best Youth)

Special Features

• Patent-pending With Heel Flex Technology, the mitt’s heel hinge is more pliable, making it simpler to close and requiring less time to break in.
• Confidence-boosting PowerClose Technology that teaches effective catching methods to young players.
• High-quality leather is used in a sturdy design.
• The deep pockets may hold the ball securely in place, making for safer catches.
• The ParaShock Palm Pad cushions your catch and lessens the pain of being hit by the ball.

A few of my younger players have utilized the Mizuno GXF102 Prospect First Base Mitt, and I can attest to its quality as a baseball coach. The mitt’s durable leather structure means it won’t need replacing for a long time.

This is especially important for younger players who are still developing their catching and fielding skills and may not always be able to make the cleanest catches.

Young athletes who continue to develop their catching skills will benefit greatly from this mitt’s PowerClose technology. They’ll have more success making safe catches, which will raise their level of confidence and encourage them to keep going.

The V-Flex notch design provides a huge advantage for younger players who may struggle to seal a more rigid mitt.

This mitt may be too small for larger players, especially those with greater experience. Those who prefer a larger first base mitt may be disappointed by its 12.5-inch circumference. However, this size is usually appropriate for younger or inexperienced players.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Patent-pending Heel Flex Technology for easier closing and reducing break-in time.
• PowerClose Technology helps young players learn proper catching techniques and build confidence.
• Durable construction made from high-quality leather.
• Deep Pocket design for better ball retention and secure catches.
• ParaShock Palm Pad reduces sting and provides a comfortable surface for catching the ball.

Cons:

• May not fit larger hands as well due to the smaller size.
• May require some break-in time before feeling comfortable to use.

MacGregor Pro 100 1st Base Mitt

Special Features

• Made from top-quality leather for durability and performance.
• The deep pocket design ensures secure catching of the ball.
• Closed back design and adjustable wrist strap for a snug fit.
• Pre-oiled leather for quick break-in and ease of use.
• Perfect for players looking for a budget-friendly option.

I’ve witnessed a wide range of first base mitts in use as a baseball coach. The MacGregor 12.5-inch first base mitt caught my eye when I first tested it. 

This mitt is made of full-grain, pre-oiled leather. This gives the mitt a wonderful feel and makes sure that it will last for a very long period.

It’s also important to note that this mitt’s pockets are deep. Players’ confidence will increase as a result of having more experience catching and hanging onto the ball.

The adjustable wrist strap is another fantastic feature that ensures a secure and comfortable fit. This is essential for young players who are still growing and will require larger mitts as they advance.

The mitt’s Velcro strap and standard back make it easy to wear. This feature benefits all players, regardless of their degree of expertise.

The only downside I can see is that this mitt might need more time to break in than others. You will, however, have a cozy and dependable mitt for a while when it has broken in.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Affordable price point.
• Lightweight and easy to maneuver.
• Soft and flexible leather material that molds to the player’s hand.
• Deep pocket design for improved catching ability.
• Suitable for both youth and adult players.

Cons

• May not have the same level of durability and performance as higher-end models.
• A limited selection of sizes and colors.

Best First Base Mitts for Softball

Mizuno GXF102 Youth Prospect First Baseman Mitt(Youth)

Special Features

• Made with full-grain leather.
• PowerClose technology for easier closure.
• Parashock Palm Pad for added protection.
• MZO lining to manage moisture.
• Lightweight and easy to maneuver.

In my experience as a baseball coach, the Mizuno GXF102 Youth Prospect First Baseman’s Mitt is a great choice for young players making their way into the position.

This mitt stands out because of its lightweight design, making it perfect for younger players. The PowerClose technology included in the mitt’s construction makes it simple for even inexperienced players to catch a ball.

The ParaShock palm pad on the Mizuno GXF102 is another highlight since it cushions your hand from strong throws and catches. This is especially helpful for younger players.

The mitt is made of sturdy leather to withstand several uses without breaking down. The Tartan Flex webbing and Deep Pocket Design give you plenty of room.

The Mizuno GXF102 Youth Prospect First Baseman’s Mitt is an excellent option for young players just starting at first base.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Affordable price point
• Lightweight and easy to maneuver for younger players
• Durable leather construction
• Deep pocket for secure ball-catching
• Comfortable fit for extended use

Cons:

• May require a break-in period for optimal performance
• Limited size options for older or larger players.

Rawlings Liberty Advanced Color Series

Special Features

• Made from premium leather for strength and flexibility.
• A double-lacing system was used in the design to increase stability and ensure a tight fit.
• The pull strap allows for a personalized fit.
• Design with deep pockets to improve catching ability.
• A range of colors is available to fit the jerseys of your team.

A top-performing choice for serious softball players is the Rawlings Liberty Advanced First Baseman Mitt. This mitt is composed of high-quality materials and is specifically intended for the first base position to provide the best performance.

The adjustable wrist strap of this mitt is one of its most notable characteristics since it enables a personalized fit to guarantee a firm hold on the ball. The mitt also has a large pocket for simpler catching, and the reinforced palm pad adds more comfort and protection.

Soft, long-lasting leather is used to create the Rawlings Liberty Advanced mitt. Due to the pre-oiling, the leather is ready to use immediately out of the package. For additional flexibility and usability, the mitt also has a fastback design.

The mitt also has Rawlings’ recognizable trademark and a fashionable design with vibrant accents. Players of various ages and ability levels can wear it because it comes in a variety of sizes.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Durability and flexibility are guaranteed by high-quality leather for the best performance.
• The wrist strap’s adjustment allows for a comfortable, personalized fit for players of all sizes.
• It is simpler to secure the ball with a deep pocket. 
• The cushioned palm pad offers additional comfort and safety during catching.
• Many colors are available. 

Cons

• Some players might find the size and design uncomfortable.
• The higher price point can be a turnoff for purchasers on a tight budget.

Buying Guide for Fist Base Mitt

Before you buy any product, you should know how to buy it, right? Therefore, I included a buying guide here. Please follow these instructions before you buy any first base mitt:

Material Issues

Many different types of materials are available on the market for first baseman’s mitts. Leather and artificial materials are the most popular choices.

Synthetic materials can give a lighter weight and more inexpensive alternative to leather while yet maintaining leather’s durability and suppleness. Prior to purchasing, make sure to weigh the benefits and drawbacks of each material.

The Fit and Size

It’s crucial to get a first baseman’s mitt that fits properly and is cozy in your hand. To make catching simpler, go for a mitt with a large, deep pocket. Consider the mitt’s size as well; a larger mitt may provide more coverage, but it may also be heavier and more difficult to maneuver.

Helpful posts: What Size Baseball Glove Do I Need

Webbing Patterns

The H-web and the single post are typically the two webbing types found on first baseman’s mitts. The H-web is a popular choice for increased stability and support, although the single post design might provide a more lightweight alternative.

When selecting a webbing style, take into account your unique needs and the type of player you are.

The popularity of a brand

It’s crucial to consider brand reputation when buying any piece of equipment. Be sure to choose well-known and respected companies in the baseball and softball communities.

Additionally, take into account reading reviews from other players to learn about their experiences with various brands and models.

Price Factors

First baseman’s mitt prices can range widely, with some models going for several hundred dollars. While it may be tempting to choose the priciest mitt available, it’s crucial to consider your budget and your actual mitt needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Difference between First Base Glove and Mitt?

Well, it seems the first base mitt and gloves are the same at first glance. But as they have different names, they come with different functions also. So, how do you differentiate a mitt from a glove, and which one is better for you?

A first base mitt is often larger and has a deeper pocket. Because, unlike a glove, it is meant to capture and hold the ball rather than just scoop it up. To better catch the ball when it’s thrown to the first base, the mitt is shaped in a way that provides a bigger surface area.

A first-base glove, on the other hand, is designed to be more maneuverable and lightweight for catching ground balls and making rapid, accurate throws. This setup is perfect for fast breaks and double plays since the player can maneuver around the court with greater ease.

Webbing is another major distinguishing feature. There are normally no openings in the leather on a first base mitt, the reason they are called “closed webs.” The catch will be more secure and comfortable as a result of this. But a first baseman’s glove, designed for more mobility and quicker ball release, typically features an open web.

So, which one should you pick? That depends on your playing style. Why not try both and choose one that suits you better?

Here is a list of the 7 best first base gloves.

What is the difference between a first base mitt and a regular fielder’s glove?

First base mitts are specially designed for the first base. The key features include a bigger pocket to catch the ball easily. Moreover, the size is bigger than outfielder gloves.

Can I use my First Base Mitt for other positions?

Although a first base mitt is intended for first basemen, it can be utilized by players of various positions. However, it might not be as efficient or as comfortable as a glove designed for that specific role. So, my suggestion is, “Don’t.”

Should I buy a synthetic or leather first base mitt?

It depends on your preference and budget. Synthetic mitts are low-priced but don’t last long. On the other hand, leather mitts will last long if you can take proper care. Lather mitts are also comfortable to wear. So, if you are a serious player, I will suggest investing in a leather mitt.

How do I break in my new first base mitt?

It can take some time and patience to break in a new first base mitt. Glove oil, a mallet, and a catch are just a few of you can apply for breaking in. Avoid applying too much power while breaking in the mitt so as not to tear the leather.

Final Words

For any serious baseball or softball player, picking the appropriate first base mitt is very important. If your first base mitt is well-fitted, well-made, and well-designed, it will do wonders for your game.

You should consider your playing style, position, and personal preferences when searching for a first base mitt. You may select a first base mitt that suits your playing style.